The unpleasant purgatory that is Clemson football in 2023
- David Hale, ESPN Personnel WriterSep 25, 2023,
- 08:00 AM ET Close ACC reporter.Joined ESPN in 2012.
- Graduate of the University of Delaware.CLEMSON, S.C.– Cade Klubnik was damaged
and defeated, his trousers splashed with blood stains, his arms covered in cuts and scrapes and scratches. He ‘d been struck– hard and consistently– by Florida State’s defense, including a sack that became a game-defining fumble recovery for a touchdown, but what he kept thinking of was that a person decision in overtime, to have a look at of a run call and into a doomed screen pass.”We’re truly, really great however 2 tough breaks,” Klubnik said.
“We have actually simply got to end up that game. We were so close.” A substantial cut spanned half of Xavier Thomas’bottom lip, but his words after Clemson’s
31-24 overtime loss to the Seminoles were clear.” It sucks, “Thomas stated. “It boiled down to a couple plays in a game we understand we need to’ve
won. We gave it to them. “Editor’s Picks 1 Related Coach Dabo Swinney arrived at the podium postgame dressed, as normal, in a neatly pressed fit, and offered a beleaguered postscript that has actually felt entirely too typical recently.” That, truthfully, was most likely as difficult a loss as I have actually ever belonged of,”Swinney said, only a small diversion from his epilogue following the Duke loss, suggesting it was the”strangest game I have actually ever been a part of.” This is the consequences of a game that felt a lot larger, a lot more significant than the final score suggested.On paper, it was a nail-biter, and inside Clemson’s locker
space, the consensus was that this was a win the Tigers let slip through their fingers.In the grander scheme of the college football hierarchy, nevertheless, Saturday seemed like an official altering of the guard, the moment when Florida State’s ascendancy intersected with Clemson’s sluggish decline.It’s possible it was both. Or neither. Possibly it doesn’t matter. Maybe the point is that the conversation is occurring at all.”We’re not entitled to win the ACC each year,”Swinney stated.”We didn’t win it in’21, and a great deal of y’
all said we were done. We returned and won it last year. “Then, including sardonically,”I believe. Didn’t we win it last year?”We do not relax imitating we’re the top group. We’ve just got to complete, show up, do our best to represent this university with class. Today wasn’t our day. I don’t look at it as a referendum. I just take a look at it as we lost the game.”Here’s where Clemson stands, four weeks into the 2023 season: The Tigers are 2-2 for the 2nd time in the past 3 years.They’re 0-2 in ACC play for the first time given that 2010, Swinney’s second year on the task and the start to a decade of consecutive 10-win seasons.They have actually lost four of their past 7 games in general, including to rivals South Carolina and Florida State.They’re at the center of a growing storm of disappointment in the middle of a fan base significantly concerned the contemporary age of college football has actually overwhelmed Swinney’s famous culture, that Clemson’s hesitation to accept the transfer portal, its people-over-players approach, its concentrate on loyalty, its vision that expands well beyond simple
talent acquisition, is in some way now a liability.And yet, to see Clemson play Florida State on Saturday was hardly an indictment of a program teetering on the brink. It was, instead, among the hardest efficiencies the Tigers have turned in given that their last nationwide title in 2018. Cade Klubnik has actually thrown nine TDs this season. AP Photo/Jacob Kupferman”I hope everyone saw what this group is really efficient in,”Klubnik said. “It’s one play and it’s a different ballgame. We played truly excellent against the No. 4 group in the nation. We saw what we deserve and at the end of the day, we simply need to complete.”This is truth for Clemson right now– not a state of panic or a go back to splendor, however rather
some uncomfortable purgatory. The Tigers no longer appear to routinely be an elite, nationwide title competitor, however they’re far too good to blow up the entire system. In 2015’s loss to South Carolina, this year’s defeat at Duke, Saturday’s dagger– they’re all
Ls in the box score that, rather fairly, Swinney can define as outliers. Heck, even the 31-14 blowout loss to Tennessee in 2015’s Capital One Orange Bowl comes with the caution that had 109 more yards and 14 more first downs but blew over consistently at a loss zone.The numbers talk to how close Clemson truly is to a totally various narrative. In the 4 losses over its past 7 games, the Tigers outgained the opposition by a minimum of 48 yards 3 times, and their total lawns margin in those four games is +196. They’ve blown numerous double-digit leads. They have actually scored simply eight goals on 17 total red-zone trips. They’ve missed out on 5 of 8 field goal attempts
, including a chip shot that may’ve won the game Saturday, kicked by a player who had actually been living in another city just a week earlier.After Saturday’s loss, Swinney regreted the fumble-turned-touchdown that signaled a major shift in the game’s vibrant as proof of the misfortune his group has actually withstood. In those 4 losses since November, Clemson is minus-five in turnover margin. Oh, how various it might’ve been.But perhaps that’s too great a line to walk. Clemson is actually even in turnover margin over its previous 7– as well as because the start of the expected decline in 2021. The Tigers have not had misfortune over a big sample size, only in the margins.For so long, Clemson controlled those margins. From 2015 to 2020– the magnificence years in Death Valley– Clemson was an impressive 24-6 when losing the turnover margin. In the previous three seasons, it’s 7-6. From 2015 to 2020, Clemson was 18-4 in one-possession
games, an elite mark. Over the past 3 seasons, it’s a more mundane 8-4. Throughout those glory years, the Tigers were 13-7 after being connected or trailing in the 2nd half, the third-best mark in the country. Considering that 2021, they’re 5-8. The point isn’t that Clemson has bad luck now.
Its luck looks more or less as one would expect. It looks, well, average. However prior to this run, Clemson’s roster was so great, so filled with famous talents like Trevor Lawrence and Travis Etienne Jr. and Tee Higgins, that luck had nothing to do with it. The Tigers won due to the fact that they were flat-out better than everybody else. Now, they’re experiencing life as simple mortals.While Florida State sustained its long march through the college football wilderness, it discovered its method to the mountaintop through a constant acquisition of skill by any means required. Clemson has actually remained the course, trusted the Swinney procedure and in doing so, the margin has gotten small enough that a few plays occasionally make a huge difference.Swinney was quick to protect his brand-new offending organizer, Garrett Riley, after Saturday’s loss. He stated Riley”called a heck of a game”and” has actually provided us a possibility to win every game because he’s been here.”Riley was Swinney’s first true outside hire in a years when he was brought on board this offseason to reignite the offense, but even Swinney noted that it was Riley’s fault that Klubnik even had a choice to switch out of a run play on third-and-1 in overtime and into a screen pass that resulted in lost yardage and, ultimately, a lost game.Swinney stated later that he had no concerns with defensive planner Wes Goodwin either. He called a number of animated sideline discussions during the game” just competing. “He didn’t acknowledge his halftime remarks that suggested the defensive strategy had actually permitted FSU’s offense to look entirely too comfortable.But fans have mainly pointed the finger at Swinney, when admired for his consistency and culture, now a things of derision for his persistent hang on The Clemson Method above all else. Clemson has a 2-2 record this season and is 0-2 in the ACC. John Byrum/Icon Sportswire It will be lost on no one at Clemson that Saturday’s game was selected a dazzling goal grab by Keon Coleman in overtime.Coleman is a transfer. So, too, is FSU’s quarterback, Jordan Travis. In fact, of Florida State’s 311 yards of total offense, 310 were collected by transfers.Swinney, nevertheless, has firmly insisted the website has little to use Clemson. He’s kicked the tires on a few people, but he landed none
beyond a couple of back-up quarterbacks. For a school that routinely lands blue-chip recruits out of high school, this 0 %success rate in the portal feels dubious.
However as numerous coaches who spoke to ESPN on the condition of anonymity argued, it doesn’t have to be a death knell.”It doesn’t imply you can’t win,”one coach said.”It just makes it tougher. It indicates you can’t miss on
your recruits. “Florida State had lost every matchup with Clemson considering that 2014, including in 2015’s 34-28 defeat in Tallahassee. And where coach Mike Norvell found holes, he filled them– with Coleman, tight end Jaheim Bell, corner Fentrell Cypress II and defensive tackle Branden Fiske, among others.Clemson’s holes have been evident, too, but Swinney thinks strongly that his own people will establish to fill the spaces. Just, in too many areas, that hasn’t happened.A place when renowned for its production of pass receivers continues to hire the position at a high level, for instance. The Tigers have actually signed nine
blue-chip receivers in their past 5 classes, however none have become All-ACC players thus far. 3 have transferred. Saturday’s game included a breakout efficiency from three-star freshman Tyler Brown, who played thoroughly with Cole Turner, provided for the year and Antonio Williams, out with an injury.The very same holds true at QB. Deshaun Watson and Lawrence were generational skills who raised Clemson to new heights.
Klubnik and DJ Uiagalelei were blue-chip potential customers, too– widely considered elite skills with tremendous upsides. Uiagalelei flamed out at Clemson and eventually transferred to Oregon State. Klubnik’s potential was on display versus FSU on Saturday, but his learning curve is clearly far steeper than that of Watson or Lawrence, who both progressed as real freshmen.That’s the point, one coach said.” They still have excellent players,”the coach said.”But they have men who’ll get drafted late or go to camps as a totally free agent, whereas previously, they had first-rounders.”Simply put, Clemson used to be able to overcome things like a bad check at the line of scrimmage or an ill-timed turnover or a weird bounce of
the ball occasionally. Heck, those things ended up being so secondary to the Tigers’ gaining ways that they barely necessitated notice.But now, the margin of error has shrunk– not to a degree that recommends Clemson can not play with practically anyone, however enough that almost anyone can also have fun with Clemson.”If you can’t see the heart of our group,”Swinney stated after Saturday’s loss,”then you’re simply blind.”He’s ideal. Clemson played with tremendous heart and grit and durability against Florida State, and Swinney has constantly appreciated those qualities above all else.The problem is Clemson wasn’t more
talented than Florida State on Saturday, and when two groups of approximately equivalent capability play a game like that– yes, a couple of plays here or there make all the distinction.